Site navigation

Smart Quotes!

Archives





Monday, December 20, 2004

Top Lawyers in England Resign over Patriot-like Laws
(original story here)

Lawyers representing foreign suspects detained under a controversial British anti-terrorism law are to resign in protest against the legislation, a few days after Britain's highest court said it was illegal.

Ian Macdonald, one of the Special Advocates authorised by the authorities to work on terrorism-related issues, announced his decision to resign, in the Mail on Sunday newspaper, after a ruling by the Law Lords - a panel of senior judges who act as the ultimate court of appeal in Britain.

The Law Lords ruled 8-1 on Thursday that the detention of nine foreigners under the law breached human rights obligations.

"Such a law is an odious blot on our legal landscape and for reasons of conscience I feel that I must resign," Macdonald wrote in the weekly.

"My role has been altered to provide a false legitimacy to indefinite detention without knowledge of the accusations being made and without any kind of criminal charge or trial." [emphasis mine]

Up to now Macdonald had stayed on because he thought he could "make a difference", despite considering it "a wrong law brought in the wrong way to the wrong court".